A STUDY OF DIVERSITY AND COMMUNITY COMPARISON INDICES BY BIOASSAY OF COPPER USING COLONIZED BENTHIC MACROINVERTEBRATES
Abstract
A community bioassay of copper was performed using benthic macroinvertebrates colonized on multiplate substrate samplers. Five copper concentrations ranging from 0.080-2.20 mg/l total copper were administered to five artificial streams by a Mount and Brungs proportional dilutor. Free copper ion as Cu('++) ranged from .002-.053 mg/l. A sixth stream received no copper and served as a control. Substrates were sampled at days 0, 14, and 28, and the results were used to compare 13 indices used or proposed to assess aquatic environmental impact. Sensitivity of the indices to changes in communities with respect to concentration and time was the basis for the comparison. Results indicated that all of the 8 diversity or richness indices tested gave approximately the same result (with the exception of number of species); they increased over the first 2-3 concentrations, then declined. Included among these was the Shannon index which gave false positive results, i.e., it increased, indicating enrichment, when in fact perturbation had occurred. This result was due to the disproportionate effect on the most abundant taxa, which caused a more even distribution of individuals among species. Number of species and individuals declined with increased concentration and time, with only one exception in the case of species, indicating perturbation. Results of five community comparison indices were varied at day 14 but by day 28 the results indicated a clear, nearly monotonic, trend due to copper impact. It was assumed that day 28 observations, though probably still changing, were nearer stability than at day 14 and therefore more representative of natural conditions. The changes in community comparison indices showed good agreement at 28 days and reflected the general decline in species and individuals. No single community comparison index could be set apart as superior to the others.
Subject Area
Environmental science
Recommended Citation
PERKINS, JIMMY LEE, "A STUDY OF DIVERSITY AND COMMUNITY COMPARISON INDICES BY BIOASSAY OF COPPER USING COLONIZED BENTHIC MACROINVERTEBRATES" (1981). Texas Medical Center Dissertations (via ProQuest). AAI8212740.
https://digitalcommons.library.tmc.edu/dissertations/AAI8212740