Randomized Controlled Trial of the CMR Immersive Virtual Reality (IVR) Headset Training Compared to E-learning for Operating Room Configuration of the CMR Versius Robot

Authors

Catherine L Eley
Varun Palaniappan
Abbie Carter
Opeyemi Sogaolu
James Horwood
Michael Davies
Jared Torkington
James Ansell

Publication Date

3-30-2024

Journal

Journal of Robotic Surgery

Abstract

Robotic surgery offers potential advantages over laparoscopic procedures, but the training for configuring robotic systems in the operating room remains underexplored. This study seeks to validate immersive virtual reality (IVR) headset training for setting up the CMR Versius in the operating room. This single-blinded randomized control trial randomised medical students with no prior robotic experience using an online randomiser. The intervention group received IVR headset training, and the control group, e-learning modules. Assessors were blinded to participant group. Primary endpoint was overall score (OS): Likert-scale 1-5: 1 reflecting independent performance, with increasing verbal prompts to a maximum score of 5, requiring physical assistance to complete the task. Secondary endpoints included task scores, time, inter-rater reliability, and concordance with participant confidence scores. Statistical analysis was performed using IBM SPSS Version 27. Of 23 participants analysed, 11 received IVR and 12 received e-learning. The median OS was lower in the IVR group than the e-learning group 53.5 vs 84.5 (p < 0.001). VR recipients performed tasks independently more frequently and required less physical assistance than e-learning participants (p < 0.001). There was no significant difference in time to completion (p = 0.880). Self-assessed confidence scores and assessor scores differed for e-learning participants (p = 0.008), though not IVR participants (p = 0.607). IVR learning is more effective than e-learning for preparing robot-naïve individuals in operating room set-up of the CMR Versius. It offers a feasible, realistic, and accessible option in resource-limited settings and changing dynamics of operating theatre teams. Ongoing deliberate practice, however, is still necessary for achieving optimal performance. ISCRTN Number 10064213.

Keywords

Humans, Clinical Competence, Computer-Assisted Instruction, Operating Rooms, Reproducibility of Results, Robotic Surgical Procedures, Robotics, Virtual Reality, Modular, Robotic, Surgery

Comments

PMID: 38554218